Tuesday, May 1, 2012

California Zinfandel vs. French Bordeaux


While I was at home in Richmond this past weekend, I enjoyed a nice dinner with my family where we decided to have a wine showdown.  The competition was between a California Zinfandel and French Bordeaux wine.  My father had returned from Paris, France two days previous to our family dinner, and brought home some bottles of wine for my family to enjoy. Coincidently, one part of this wine and food pairing went perfect with our lecture on Thursday focusing on French wines, so I felt very knowledgeable around the dinner table and didn’t hold back to offer my wisdom when I could.   
Learning in lecture, that France is still the “Disney World” of wines, I was very excited to try the wine my Dad brought back.  It was a Boudreaux wine from Chateau La Rose Beausejour. The Grand Vin De Bourdeux is from the Cotes De Castillon region.  It was bottled in 2007 “mis en boutelle au chateau”, which translates to bottled at the chateau.  
            I opened the bottle and poured a little in the glass to observe the color, smell, and taste. I brought the glass up to eye level and saw a medium ruby color. I swirled the glass in an attempt to observe the legs and noticed a fair amount of reminiscence on the glass. Upon initial smell, I got hints of cigars, subtle of earthy tones, and a crisp bark. The aromatics enticed me to try the wine and see what it tasted like on the pallet.  Upon tasting it, it went down smoothly and tasted similar to the aromatics.  It was definitely a medium to full-bodied Boudreaux that presented bold flavors on the palate.  I tasted spices with a hint of earthiness in this wine.  Although I have tasted spicy wines before, this spice was not overwhelming and was very smooth in my mouth. 
            After sampling the Grand Vin De Bourdeux, I was sure that no one could compare.  However, I was very impressed with the Summerland 2006 Zinfandel.  The grape used to make this wine is originally from Croatia and is widely planted throughout California.  
            The Summerland Zinfandel is a dark purple color with evident tannins upon swirling.  When I took a sniffy sniff I smelled berries, spice, and a lot of pepper.  I was expecting the wine to be very spicy when I tasted it after the definite spice aroma, but I was very surprised when I tasted it.  I tasted a relatively sweet flavor, almost a mix of berries and vanilla flavoring.  I swirled it in my mouth, and appreciated the smoothness upon swallowing. 
After about ten minutes, I tasted the wine again and started tasting more hints of spice and pepper.  I thought this wine was very balanced and offered a good variety of flavors.  For about $20, I thought this wine offered excellent value and a variety of flavors that make it compatible with an array of foods. 
            My family chose to Asian lettuce wraps to pair with the Boudreaux and Zinfandel wine.  The spiciness of the Asian lettuce wraps paired with I think it paired very well and was compatible with the pallet. 
            The competition was pretty tight between the two wines, but I think I favored the Grand Vin De Boudreaux a little more than the Summerland Zinfandel.  I thought the Summerland almost offered too many flavors that made it confusing where are the Bordeaux was bold and all encompassing of earthy tones.